Succulent Terrarium: Why Open Glass Only
The succulent jars in photos usually have lids. Real succulents under a lid rot. Here is how to build one that lasts.
A succulent terrarium that turned to mush in a month is one of the most common plant disappointments there is, and it usually happens to people who did everything the picture showed. The picture was the problem.
Here is the hopeful part: succulents are among the easiest plants to keep under glass, as long as the glass is open. Take the lid off, use gritty soil, water far less than feels right, and give them your brightest window. That is the whole fix.
Succulent terrarium in short: open glass only, never a lid · a wide mouth for air and access · 5–8 cm of gritty cactus mix · small, slow succulents such as haworthia and echeveria · water a little at the base only when the mix is dry all the way down · brightest window, and a grow light from November to February in most Canadian homes.
Why Closed Jars Rot Succulents
If your last one rotted, it was not bad luck and it was not you. A closed terrarium is built to do one thing: keep water inside. It evaporates from the soil, beads on the glass and runs back down, so the air stays humid and the soil stays damp. That is perfect for a fern.
A succulent stores water in its leaves and expects the soil around its roots to dry out completely between drinks. In a closed jar it never does. Roots sit in damp mix, the base of the plant stays wet, and rot starts there, usually hidden under the leaves until the plant collapses. Mississippi State Extension says succulents and cacti “would quickly rot and die” in a closed system, and Penn State puts it just as plainly: they do not belong in closed terrariums.
Oklahoma State Extension goes further and says cacti and succulents are not well adapted to terrariums at all, recommending a dish garden instead. That is a useful way to think about it: a good succulent terrarium is really a dish garden that happens to be made of glass, open to the room, wide enough for air to move.
How to Build an Open Succulent Terrarium
Not sure your container will work? If the opening is at least as wide as your hand, it almost certainly will.
- Pick wide, open glass. A bowl, a shallow tank, a cut-open globe or a wide vase. The wider the mouth, the faster the soil dries, which is what you want. Avoid tall, narrow vases where air sits still at the bottom.
- A thin base layer (optional). A centimetre or two of gravel shows you through the glass if water is pooling. It does not make overwatering safe; see the note on drainage layers in terrarium layers.
- Gritty mix, 5–8 cm. Bagged cactus and succulent mix, or regular potting mix cut with plenty of perlite or coarse grit. Our potting mix recipes include a succulent blend.
- Plant with space. Leave a finger-width between plants so air reaches the base of each. Set them at the same depth they grew in the pot, not deeper.
- Top with fine gravel or sand. It keeps the base of each rosette dry and looks finished.
- Wait before watering. Give it about a week so any roots broken during planting can callus over, then give the first light drink.
Want everything in one box? Many kits sold as succulent terrarium kits include a lidded jar; leave the lid off. Our page on terrarium kits explains what to look for.
Which Succulents Do Best
Glass cuts a little of the light, and a Canadian winter cuts a lot more, so choose succulents that cope with less than a desert windowsill. Haworthia is the best start: it grows slowly and tolerates bright indirect light. Small echeveria and burro’s tail want more sun.
| Plant | Botanical name | Pets | Guide |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peperomia | Peperomia (small species) | Non-toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| Echeveria | Echeveria | Non-toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| Haworthia | Haworthia | Non-toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| Burro's tail | Sedum morganianum | Non-toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| Hens and chicks | Sempervivum | No ASPCA listing; keep out of reach | Care guide |
| Air plant | Tillandsia | No ASPCA listing; keep out of reach | Care guide |
| Jade plant | Crassula ovata | Toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| Aloe | Aloe vera | Toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
| String of pearls | Curio rowleyanus | Toxic to cats and dogs (ASPCA) | Care guide |
Pet status from the ASPCA plant database. Peperomia also grows in open glass, though it is not a true succulent. For more choices see best succulents for Canada and best plants for terrariums.
Watering a Container With No Drainage Hole
Scared of watering because there is nowhere for the water to go? That instinct is right, and it is easy to work with: give small, measured drinks, and let your eyes do the checking.
- Water only when the mix is dry all the way down. Push a chopstick to the bottom; if it comes out with damp soil on it, wait.
- Pour at the base, not over the top. A squeeze bottle or a spoon puts water at the roots and keeps it out of the rosettes, where it causes rot.
- Small amounts. Enough to moisten the root zone, not the whole bowl. If you see water collecting in the gravel at the bottom, you gave too much; tip the bowl gently or wick it out with a paper towel.
- Much less in winter. In a cool, dim Canadian house from November to February, every three to five weeks is common. Shrivelling, slightly soft leaves mean thirsty; translucent, mushy or black ones mean too wet.
Winter Light in a Canadian Home
Your succulents leaning, stretching and fading from red to pale green by February? That is the most common succulent problem in Canada, and it is light, not care.
An open succulent bowl is the one terrarium that can go right in a sunny south or west window, since it has no lid to trap heat. Even there, a December day is short: about 8h55 of daylight in Toronto and 7h54 in Calgary. A small LED grow light on a 12-hour timer keeps them compact until March. Our page on terrarium light covers distance and hours, and how to make succulents turn red explains the colour.
Succulent Terrarium FAQ
Can succulents live in a closed terrarium?
No, not for long. A closed jar keeps the air humid and the soil damp, and succulents need dry air and long dry spells. Mississippi State and Penn State Extension both say succulents and cacti do not belong in closed terrariums because they rot. Use an open bowl, globe or tank with no lid.
How do you make a succulent terrarium?
Use an open glass container with a wide mouth. Add a thin layer of gravel if you like, then 5 to 8 cm of gritty cactus and succulent mix. Plant small succulents with a little space between them, top with fine gravel or sand, and wait about a week before the first light watering so any broken roots can heal. Place it in your brightest window.
How often do you water a succulent terrarium?
Only when the mix is dry all the way down, which in a Canadian winter can mean every three to five weeks. Because there is no drainage hole, give a small amount poured at the base of each plant rather than soaking the bowl, and check through the glass that no water is pooling at the bottom.
Why is my succulent terrarium dying?
The usual cause is too much water in a container that cannot drain: soft, translucent or black leaves at the base mean rot. The second cause is low light: stretched, pale plants leaning toward the window mean the bowl needs a brighter spot or a grow light, which is common in Canadian homes from November to February.
What succulents are best for a terrarium?
Small, slow ones that tolerate a little less light than a desert windowsill: haworthia first, then small echeveria, burro's tail and hens and chicks. The ASPCA lists haworthia, echeveria and burro's tail as non-toxic to cats and dogs. Jade, aloe and string of pearls are toxic per the ASPCA.
Can I put cactus in a terrarium?
Only in open glass, and only small, slow ones. Oklahoma State Extension notes that cacti and succulents are not well adapted to terrariums because of the humidity, and suggests a dish garden instead. An open, wide container in a sunny window is really a dish garden in glass, which is what works.
Sources
- Mississippi State University Extension, How to Design a Closed-System Terrarium (P3253) — succulents and cacti rot in closed systems.
- Penn State Extension, Creating a Closed Terrarium — succulents and cacti do not belong in closed terrariums.
- Oklahoma State University Extension, Terrariums (HLA-6438) — cacti and succulents not well adapted to terrariums; a dish garden instead.
- Iowa State University Extension, How to Create and Care for a Terrarium — cacti and succulents struggle in humidity.
- ASPCA Animal Poison Control, Toxic and Non-Toxic Plants — pet status for each plant.