Growing Mums in Canada
Why the mum you bought in September is usually dead by May, and how to grow one that comes back.
Growing mums in Canada as perennials is possible, but not the way most people try it. Every fall, garden centres and grocery stores sell pots of chrysanthemums (Chrysanthemum × morifolium) in full bloom. Many go into the garden in October and never come back. The plant is not always the problem; the timing and the type usually are.
This guide explains the difference between garden mums and florist mums, why fall planting fails, how to plant and mulch so a mum survives, and which mums are bred for the coldest parts of Canada.
Mums at a glance: buy garden (hardy) mums, not florist mums, and plant them in spring if you want them back. Most are rated to US Zone 5; University of Minnesota cultivars to US Zone 3. Full sun, soil that drains. Mulch about 10 cm once the ground starts to freeze. Pinch until early July, then stop. A fall-bought pot is safest kept in its pot in a cold garage or basement over winter.
Garden Mums vs Florist Mums
Mums bloom in response to long nights. The University of Illinois explains that each cultivar needs a certain length of darkness before it sets flower buds, which is why some are labelled early and others late. Florist mums need such long nights that, outdoors, a killing frost arrives before they can bloom. The University of Minnesota is blunt about the stacks of mums outside big-box and grocery stores: they are florist mums, fine for porch pots, but not bred to survive a Minnesota winter.
Garden mums, also sold as hardy mums, are cultivars bred for winter hardiness. Even these are not as tough as their name suggests. The University of Missouri says the word "hardy" is misleading: cultivars vary widely, and most garden mums need some winter protection to survive, especially their first winter. If a tag does not name a hardiness zone, treat the plant as seasonal decor.
Which Zones Can Grow Mums?
The University of Illinois, Missouri and NC State all rate garden mums to about US Zone 5. The University of Minnesota has bred mums since 1977 and describes its cultivars as reliably hardy in US Zones 3 to 9. Its program also produced the large Mammoth series, which can reach 90 to 120 cm (3 to 4 feet) across by the second year and whose frost tolerance keeps them blooming into October.
These are US (USDA) zones. Canadian zones use a different formula, so a Canadian Zone 4 is not the same as a US Zone 4. See USDA vs Canadian zones, or find yours with the zone finder. The fall frost date matters as much as the zone: Missouri says most hardy mums start their flower buds in mid to late July and need 6 to 10 more weeks to bloom. Where the first frost comes early, choose early-blooming cultivars.
| Region | City | Canadian zone | Average first fall frost | Frost-free days |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BC coast | Vancouver | 9a | November 4 | 224 |
| BC Interior | Kelowna | 7a | September 23 | 130 |
| Alberta | Calgary | 4a | September 10 | 106 |
| Alberta | Edmonton | 4a | September 11 | 110 |
| Saskatchewan | Regina | 3a | September 11 | 108 |
| Manitoba | Winnipeg | 3b | September 22 | 119 |
| Southern Ontario | Toronto | 7a | October 9 | 156 |
| Southern Ontario | London | 6b | October 11 | 156 |
| Eastern Ontario | Ottawa | 5a | October 2 | 152 |
| Quebec | Montreal | 5b | October 9 | 161 |
| Atlantic | Halifax | 6b | October 17 | 159 |
| Atlantic | Charlottetown | 5b | October 17 | 154 |
Zones are NRCan 1991–2020; frost dates and season length are Environment and Climate Change Canada 1991–2020 normals.
Why Fall-Planted Mums Die
The University of Illinois names the main reason directly: we plant mums when they are for sale, in the fall, and that is the wrong time. A plant in full bloom puts its energy into flowers, not roots, and a mum's roots are shallow to begin with. Through the winter, freezing and thawing lifts shallow-rooted plants out of the ground. Missouri calls this frost heaving and says it can severely damage or kill them.
Missouri adds that a mum planted from its pot after flowering has a limited chance of surviving, even with mulch, because it is too late in the year to grow the roots it needs. Virginia Cooperative Extension, writing for a much milder climate, gives the same advice: the later mums are planted, the lower the survival rate.
How to Plant Mums So They Come Back
- Plant in spring. The University of Illinois says spring is the ideal time, because it gives plants a whole season to establish. Missouri says to plant in spring once the soil begins to warm.
- If you plant in fall, go early and small. Virginia Cooperative Extension recommends smaller plants (about 1-quart pots) that have not started flowering yet, planted as early as possible. Compare your first fall frost in the table: in the Prairies it comes early, so a fall mum has very little time.
- Sun and drainage. All the sources ask for at least 6 hours of direct sun and soil that drains. Illinois says to avoid low spots and heavy soil, because mums do not like wet feet, and suggests a sheltered spot such as near the house.
- Water. Shallow roots dry out fast. Illinois says drought-stressed plants are less likely to survive the winter, and Virginia says to keep watering until the first hard frost.
Avoid planting near street lights or a bright porch light. Illinois explains that light at night interrupts the dark period the plant needs and can delay flowering.
Winter Protection: Mulch, and the Cut-Back Question
Mulch is the step every source agrees on. Illinois says to add about 10 cm (4 inches) of mulch when the ground begins to freeze; its 2017 article gives 10 to 15 cm of straw after the ground freezes. Missouri suggests a loose, airy mulch such as straw, pine needles or evergreen boughs, anchored against the wind. Its point is not to keep the plant warm but to keep the soil from freezing and thawing over and over. Missouri says to pull the mulch back from the crown by early to mid-April, once severe cold has passed.
On cutting back, the sources disagree. Illinois and Virginia say to leave the old stems standing over winter as extra protection, then remove them in spring when new growth starts. Missouri says to cut the tops back once the leaves turn brown, then mulch. Both are extension advice; mulch matters more than which one you choose.
Last year's mum stems are dry and woody by spring. Sharp bypass pruners cut them cleanly at the base without pulling on the shallow crown, whether you clear them in April as Illinois suggests or after the leaves brown in fall as Missouri does.
Affiliate link — GrowersGuide.ca may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
Keeping a Fall-Bought Mum in Its Pot
If your mum arrived in September in full bloom, Missouri and Virginia both suggest overwintering it in its pot instead of planting it. Missouri gives three options: a cold frame; a bright window in a cool room at about 4 to 7 °C (40 to 45 °F); or cut the plant back to a few centimetres above the soil and keep the pot in the corner of a basement or an insulated garage where it will not freeze, watering lightly only when the mix is dry. Plant it in the garden in spring once the soil begins to warm.
Pinching, Feeding and Dividing
In spring, when new shoots reach about 15 cm (6 inches), pinch off the tips to make a bushier plant with more flowers. Illinois says you can pinch two or three times; its 2017 article starts at 20 to 25 cm. Both Illinois and Missouri use early July as the last pinch, because Missouri says most hardy mums start forming flower buds in mid to late July.
Missouri calls mums heavy feeders that need water and fertilizer through the summer. Illinois suggests fertilizing once a month from spring, with July as the last month. Illinois also recommends dividing every few years in spring, as new growth appears: dig the clump, discard the old centre, and replant pieces with several shoots and good roots.
Troubleshooting Mums
| What you see | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Fall-planted mum dead in spring | Planted too late; few roots; possibly a florist mum (Illinois, Missouri, UMN) | Plant hardy mums in spring; keep fall pots in a cold garage instead. |
| Crown pushed up out of the soil | Frost heaving (Missouri, Illinois) | Mulch about 10 cm once the ground starts to freeze. |
| Buds but no flowers before frost | Late cultivar or florist mum (Illinois) | Choose early-blooming hardy cultivars. |
| Flowering delayed near a light | Night lighting (Illinois) | Move the plant away from street or porch lights. |
| Tall, floppy plant with few flowers | Not pinched, or too much shade (Illinois, NC State) | Pinch until early July; give 6 or more hours of sun. |
| No flowers after a late pinch | Pinched after early July (Missouri) | Stop pinching by early July next year. |
| White powder or spots on leaves | Powdery mildew or leaf spot (NC State) | Space plants for air; water the soil, not the leaves. |
| Weak plant with a dead centre | Clump needs dividing (Illinois) | Divide in spring and discard the old centre. |
Pets
NC State lists garden mums as a problem for cats and for children, with low severity: stomach upset or vomiting if eaten, and a mild rash from the leaves in some sensitive people. Also check the ASPCA list of toxic and non-toxic plants, and call your veterinarian if your pet eats part of a plant.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will the mums I bought in the fall come back next year?
Often not. The University of Illinois says the biggest reason mums fail to overwinter is that they are planted in the fall, when they are for sale, instead of in spring. Missouri says mums in their purchase pots after flowering have a limited chance if planted that late, because there is no time to grow the roots they need. Many of the mums sold in fall are also florist mums, which the University of Minnesota says are not bred to survive a northern winter.
What is the difference between garden mums and florist mums?
Garden or hardy mums are cultivars bred for winter hardiness. Florist mums are sold for decoration and are not. The University of Illinois explains that mums bloom when nights get long, and florist types need nights so long that a killing frost arrives before they flower outdoors.
Are mums hardy in Canada?
Most garden mums are rated to US Zone 5, according to the University of Illinois, Missouri and NC State. The University of Minnesota breeds mums it describes as reliably hardy in US Zones 3 to 9. Even so, Missouri says most garden mums need some winter protection, especially in their first winter.
Should I cut back mums in the fall?
The sources disagree. The University of Illinois and Virginia Cooperative Extension say to leave the dead stems over winter as extra protection and remove them in spring. Missouri says to cut back the tops after the leaves turn brown and then mulch. Either way, mulch is the part they all agree on.
When is the best time to plant mums?
Spring. The University of Illinois says spring gives the plants time to establish. If you plant in fall, plant as early as you can, ideally small plants that have not started flowering, as Virginia Cooperative Extension advises.
When should I stop pinching mums?
Around early July. The University of Illinois and Missouri both use the first week of July (July 4) as the last pinch. Pinching later removes the flower buds the plant starts to form in mid to late July.
Are mums toxic to cats?
NC State lists garden mums as a problem for cats and for children, with low severity: stomach upset or vomiting if eaten, and a mild rash from the leaves in some people. Check the ASPCA list as well, and call your veterinarian if your cat has eaten part of a plant.
Sources
- University of Illinois Extension — Why do my mums always die? (2021)
- University of Illinois Extension — Fall Garden Mums in the Garden (2017)
- University of Missouri IPM — Winter Care of Hardy Mums
- Virginia Tech — How to overwinter fall mums, according to Virginia Cooperative Extension experts
- University of Minnesota Extension — Hardy mums provide color that returns every fall
- University of Minnesota — Chrysanthemum breeding
- NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox — Chrysanthemum × morifolium