Growing Black-Eyed Susans in Canada
Two different plants share the name. Knowing which one you bought explains why it vanished, or why it took over.
Growing black-eyed Susans in Canada starts with a question most plant tags skip: which Rudbeckia is it? The two you will find at a garden centre behave differently. One lives a year or two and keeps itself going by seed. The other forms a clump that gets bigger every year.
Both are tough. NC State Extension rates both to US Zone 3a, lists them as tolerant of drought and deer, and says both bloom from summer into fall. Both are native to the eastern United States and feed butterflies and other pollinators.
Black-eyed Susans at a glance: Rudbeckia hirta is short-lived and self-seeds. Rudbeckia fulgida is a long-lived perennial that spreads into clumps. Both are rated to US Zone 3a, prefer full sun and any soil that is not soggy. Go easy on fertilizer. Leave the seed heads for winter birds. Black-eyed Susan vine is a different, tender plant.
The Two Black-Eyed Susans
Rudbeckia hirta — short-lived, flowers the first year
NC State calls it a fast-growing biennial or short-lived perennial. Because it flowers in its first year when sown in early spring, it is often taken for an annual. It reaches 60 cm to 1.2 m, has hairy leaves and stems, and seeds itself freely, so a patch usually stays even as single plants die. Cultivars include 'Indian Summer', 'Cherry Brandy' and 'Denver Daisy'.
Rudbeckia fulgida — long-lived, spreads into clumps
A true perennial that spreads by underground stems (rhizomes) into large clumps, NC State says. It grows 60 to 90 cm, keeps a low rosette of leaves through the winter, and NC State lists no significant problems. Garden centres usually sell named cultivars rather than the wild species; 'Goldsturm' is the best known, and NC State lists 'Early Bird Gold', 'Little Goldstar' and 'Viette's Little Suzy' (25 to 40 cm).
Sun, Soil and Fertilizer
NC State gives the same light for both: full sun is best, part shade is tolerated. R. fulgida grows in any soil except a soggy one, and R. hirta takes clay, loam or sand as long as it drains.
The common mistake is too much food. NC State says moderate fertility gives the best flowers, and warns against planting R. hirta along lawn edges, where lawn fertilizer adds extra nitrogen. Rich, heavily fed soil grows leaves and floppy stems; tall flower heads may need staking even in average soil.
Seed, Planting and Dividing
R. hirta from seed: sown in early spring it flowers the same summer, which is why it is an easy start for a new bed. Let a few flowers ripen in fall and it will reseed. R. fulgida: NC State says it is propagated by division in spring or fall, or from seed. Lift a section from the edge of the clump and replant it at the same depth.
West Coast Seeds, a BC seed company, sells flower seed by mail. A packet of Rudbeckia hirta sown in spring gives flowers the same year.
🌼 Shop flower seeds at West Coast Seeds →Affiliate link — we may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Deadheading and Winter
With deadheading, NC State says R. hirta keeps flowering from midsummer into mid-fall. Stop deadheading late in the season so some seed ripens. For R. fulgida, NC State suggests leaving the seed heads on as winter food for birds; the dark cones standing above the snow are part of the plant's appeal, and the winter rosette at the base stays put.
Black-Eyed Susan Vine Is a Different Plant
The University of Wisconsin is clear that black-eyed Susan vine (Thunbergia alata) is completely unrelated to Rudbeckia. It is a tender plant from East Africa, hardy only in US Zones 9a and 10a, and is grown as an annual in cold climates. Wisconsin's advice: start seed indoors 6 to 8 weeks before the average last frost, and plant out once frost has passed and nights stay above 10 °C (50 °F).
Worked out from each city's average last frost:
| Region | City | Zone | Average last frost | Start vine seed indoors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BC coast | Vancouver | 9a | March 26 | January 29–February 12 |
| BC Interior | Kelowna | 7a | May 16 | March 21–April 4 |
| Alberta | Edmonton | 4a | May 22 | March 27–April 10 |
| Saskatchewan | Saskatoon | 3a | May 22 | March 27–April 10 |
| Manitoba | Winnipeg | 3b | May 24 | March 29–April 12 |
| Southern Ontario | Toronto | 7a | May 4 | March 9–23 |
| Eastern Ontario | Ottawa | 5a | May 7 | March 12–26 |
| Quebec | Montreal | 5b | April 29 | March 4–18 |
| Quebec | Quebec City | 5a | May 11 | March 16–30 |
| Maritimes | Halifax | 6b | May 8 | March 13–27 |
| Maritimes | Charlottetown | 5b | May 18 | March 23–April 6 |
| Newfoundland | St. John's | 6a | June 1 | April 6–20 |
Zones are NRCan 1991–2020. Last frost is the Environment and Climate Change Canada 1991–2020 normal: frost has passed by then in half of years, so wait for warm nights before planting out. Other cities: frost calculator.
Troubleshooting Black-Eyed Susans
| What you see | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Plant gone after a year or two | R. hirta is short-lived (NC State) | Normal. Let some flowers set seed, or plant R. fulgida for a lasting clump. |
| Lots of leaves, floppy stems, few flowers | Too much nitrogen, e.g. lawn fertilizer (NC State) | Stop feeding; move plants away from fertilized lawn edges. Stake tall heads. |
| White powder on the leaves | Powdery mildew, which R. hirta is prone to (NC State) | Give plants more space and sun; water the soil, not the leaves. |
| Ragged holes, slime trails | Slugs and snails (NC State) | Pick them off by hand. |
| Clump spreading past its spot | R. fulgida spreads by rhizomes (NC State) | Divide in spring or fall and replant or give away the extra. |
| Plant died over winter | Wet soil (NC State: any soil but a soggy one) | Both kinds want soil that drains. Replant in a better-drained spot. |
| A "black-eyed Susan" died at first frost | It was the vine, Thunbergia alata (UW-Madison) | That plant is tender. Start it indoors each spring. |
Pets
We do not make safety claims about plants and pets. Check the ASPCA list of toxic and non-toxic plants, and call your veterinarian if your pet eats part of a plant.
Hoops hold a frost cover clear of the leaves, so the fabric does not chill them where it touches. They also turn a bed into a low tunnel for spring and fall.
Affiliate link — GrowersGuide.ca may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do black-eyed Susans come back every year in Canada?
It depends which one you have. Rudbeckia hirta is a biennial or short-lived perennial, so a single plant may only last a year or two, but NC State says it freely self-seeds and usually stays in the garden through its seedlings. Rudbeckia fulgida is a true perennial that spreads by underground stems into larger clumps every year.
Are black-eyed Susans hardy in Canada?
NC State rates both Rudbeckia hirta and Rudbeckia fulgida to US Zone 3a, which covers most populated parts of Canada. Canadian and US zones are calculated differently, so check your Canadian zone and compare.
Do black-eyed Susans need full sun?
They do best in full sun and tolerate part shade, according to NC State. In more shade they bloom less.
Should I deadhead black-eyed Susans?
Deadheading keeps Rudbeckia hirta blooming from midsummer into the middle of fall, NC State says. Leave the last flowers to ripen if you want seedlings next year, and leave the seed heads of Rudbeckia fulgida over winter as food for birds.
When should I divide black-eyed Susans?
Divide Rudbeckia fulgida in spring or fall, according to NC State. Rudbeckia hirta is short-lived and is usually kept going from seed instead of by division.
Is black-eyed Susan vine the same plant?
No. The University of Wisconsin says black-eyed Susan vine (Thunbergia alata) is completely unrelated. It is a tender African plant, hardy only in US Zones 9a and 10a, so in Canada it is grown as an annual started indoors 6 to 8 weeks before the last frost.
Are black-eyed Susans safe for cats and dogs?
We do not make safety claims about plants and pets. Check the ASPCA list of toxic and non-toxic plants, and ask your veterinarian if your pet has eaten part of a plant.