Loading…

Winter Composting in Canada: What Still Breaks Down

Winter composting in Canada is mostly a matter of not giving up in November. Across most of the country an outdoor pile freezes for months, and that is fine: the scraps you add wait in the cold and break down once the pile thaws. What you can control is how big and well covered the pile is going into winter, whether you can still reach it through the snow, and how quickly you get it going again in spring.

Quick answer: yes, you can compost in winter. Cold slows composting rather than stopping it, and a frozen pile simply pauses. Go into winter with a large, covered pile and a half-empty bin, stop turning once it freezes, and keep adding kitchen scraps. If the bin is buried, use a worm bin, a Bokashi bucket or your green bin until spring. After the thaw, turn it and add dry browns.

What Still Breaks Down Below Freezing

Composting is done by microbes, and different ones work at different temperatures. Illinois Extension explains that the hot phase runs on bacteria that thrive between about 45 and 75 °C, and that below about 20 °C cold-tolerant bacteria take over and work more slowly. Its conclusion: extremely cold temperatures slow composting down rather than stopping it completely.

Size decides how long a pile keeps working. A large pile makes and holds more heat in its centre; Illinois Extension says smaller piles are prone to freezing, which halts active composting until spring. Oregon State University Extension describes the usual result: the outer few centimetres of a pile frozen solid and not much happening inside.

For a typical Canadian backyard bin, that means some breakdown through November and again in March, and a long pause in between. Oregon State’s compost specialist is relaxed about that pause, and so should you be: nothing is wasted, and a pile that froze in January is ready to work hard in April.

Getting the Pile Ready in the Fall

Everything that helps a pile through winter has to happen before it freezes; Oregon State notes that insulating a pile only works while it is still warm. In October and November:

  • Build it big. Illinois Extension advises increasing pile size at the start of the cold season, and its general guidance is a pile of about 1 to 1.5 m on each side (3 to 5 feet). Fall leaves make bulk easy.
  • Cover it, but let it breathe. Illinois says a winter pile or bin should be covered against excess rain and snow while still allowing air flow. Illinois notes that too much water leaches nutrients and can leave an active pile short of air.
  • Insulate the top. Illinois suggests a layer of finished compost, woodchips or straw, or a compost cover. Oregon State adds straw or hay bales stacked around the pile, placed while it is still hot.
  • Empty the bin. Use or move finished compost in the fall so the bin has room. A University of Saskatchewan study of 26 composting methods found that large bins had space to stockpile frozen scraps through winter, while small ones filled up.
  • Bag some dry leaves. Keep a few bags in the garage or shed. They are the browns you will cover winter scraps with, and the browns you will need in spring.
Recommended
Large Compost Bin

For a Canadian winter, capacity matters more than features. The University of Saskatchewan study found large stationary bins had room to stockpile frozen scraps until spring. Pick the biggest closed bin your space allows, with a lid that sheds snow and a hatch at the bottom for finished compost.

Browse on Amazon.ca →

Affiliate link — GrowersGuide.ca may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.

What to Do With a Frozen Bin

  • Keep adding kitchen scraps. They freeze in layers and break down after the thaw. Chop large pieces first; they break down faster in spring.
  • Cover each addition with a handful of dry leaves or shredded cardboard when you can. It keeps the balance of browns and greens and the smell down in spring.
  • Stop turning. Illinois Extension recommends no turning after November, or once temperatures stay below freezing, to keep heat in the centre. A frozen pile cannot be turned anyway.
  • Keep the lid on and brush off heavy snow, which melts into the pile in spring.
  • Shovel a path. Illinois Extension’s first question about winter composting is whether you can still get to the bin. If you will not walk out to it in February, plan an indoor option instead.

A tumbler is the weak spot in winter. In the Saskatchewan study, tumblers were small, did not fare well in winter, and their doors sometimes froze shut. If a tumbler is your only bin, empty it in the fall and treat it as a spring-to-fall tool, with an indoor bin or a stockpile beside it for the winter.

Recommended
Compost Tumbler

A tumbler is the easiest bin to turn and the most rodent-proof from spring to fall, but in a Canadian winter it fills up and can freeze shut. If you buy one, a two-chamber model lets one side finish while you fill the other, and it pairs best with a larger stationary bin or a worm bin for the winter months.

Browse on Amazon.ca →

Affiliate link — GrowersGuide.ca may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.

Indoor Options for the Winter

Illinois Extension suggests switching to an indoor method or a collection service during the coldest months if the outdoor pile is out of reach. The University of Saskatchewan found indoor methods work through the winter, with less room for error on smell and pests.

A worm bin

The University of Saskatchewan’s method: a plastic tub with holes cut near the top of the lid and sides, 5–8 cm of damp shredded cardboard or newspaper, and red wiggler worms. Bury every addition of food scraps under at least 2–3 cm of bedding to keep fruit flies away, and add dry bedding if the lid drips or the bin smells. Red wigglers die in a hard frost, so the bin stays inside all winter.

A Bokashi bucket

A sealed kitchen bucket with an inoculated bran that takes food scraps and turns them into material you bury in the garden or add to the outdoor pile once it thaws. Illinois and the University of Saskatchewan both list it as a winter option.

Your city’s green bin

Many Canadian municipalities collect food scraps at the curb or at a drop-off. Using it from December to March is not cheating; it keeps scraps out of the garbage while the backyard bin is frozen. Check what your municipality accepts.

Whichever you use, a lidded kitchen caddy by the sink makes winter scraps easier to collect between trips outside.

Recommended
Kitchen Compost Caddy

In winter, trips out to the bin are fewer, so scraps sit in the kitchen longer. A countertop caddy with a sealing lid holds a few days of peels and coffee grounds, and a removable liner makes it easy to empty into the outdoor bin, the worm bin or the green bin.

Browse on Amazon.ca →

Affiliate link — GrowersGuide.ca may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.

Getting Ready for Spring

Oregon State advises waiting until temperatures are reliably above freezing, at least in the daytime, before working the pile. Then, following Illinois Extension’s spring routine:

  1. Check it. Look for things that should not be there, such as branches or garbage, and repair a cracked bin.
  2. See if it is still working. Steam, or finished compost at the bottom or middle, means parts of the pile kept going.
  3. Turn it with a fork, bringing the outside to the centre. After the thaw a pile is usually wet and soggy, so turn it rather than adding water.
  4. Add browns. Illinois suggests about three buckets of dry browns (leaves, straw) for every bucket of fresh greens. The bagged leaves from the fall go in now.
  5. Turn about once a week after that, and water only if it dries out.

For the basics of browns, greens and a pile that heats up, see how to compost in Canada. For which bin suits your zone, see composting in Canada, and to size a bin, the composting calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you compost in the winter in Canada?

Yes. Keep adding kitchen scraps to the outdoor bin all winter even though the pile freezes; nothing is lost, it just waits for spring. Illinois Extension says cold slows composting rather than stopping it outright, and a large pile keeps working longest. If you cannot reach the bin through the snow, switch to a worm bin, a Bokashi bucket or your city's green bin until spring.

Does compost break down in the winter?

Slowly, and in a small bin hardly at all. Illinois Extension explains that the hot phase of composting runs on bacteria that thrive between about 45 and 75 °C, and that below about 20 °C cold-tolerant bacteria take over and work more slowly. A large, well-built pile can keep a warm core into the winter; a small bin freezes, and Illinois says freezing halts active composting until it thaws.

Should I turn my compost in winter?

No. Illinois Extension recommends stopping turning after November, or whenever temperatures stay below freezing, so the heat in the centre is not let out. A frozen pile cannot be turned anyway. The first turn of the year comes in spring, once the pile has thawed.

What do I do with a frozen compost bin?

Keep filling it. Scraps freeze in layers and start breaking down again when the pile thaws. Throw a handful of dry leaves or shredded cardboard over each addition if you can, keep the lid on against snow and rain, and make sure there is room: a University of Saskatchewan study found large bins had space to stockpile frozen scraps, while small tumblers filled up and their doors sometimes froze shut.

How do I compost indoors in winter?

A worm bin is the classic answer. The University of Saskatchewan's method: a plastic tub with air holes near the top, 5 to 8 cm of damp shredded cardboard or newspaper, red wiggler worms, and every addition of food buried under bedding. Red wigglers die in a hard frost, so the bin lives indoors all winter. Bokashi buckets also work indoors through the winter.

How do I get my compost going again in spring?

Once the pile has thawed, check it for things that should not be there, then turn it with a fork. Illinois Extension notes a pile is usually wet and soggy after the thaw, so turn it rather than adding water, and mix in about three buckets of dry browns for every bucket of fresh greens. Then turn it about once a week.

🪪 More Composting and Soil Guides

Sources

Was this guide helpful?

Tap or press a star to rate

Save to Pinterest

🌱 Free Newsletter

Get New Guides Before Anyone Else

Planting reminders for your city, new calculators, and Canadian growing guides — free, no spam.

Suggest what we write next →

⭐ Most Popular

Weather data by Open-Meteo.com (CC BY 4.0) · © OpenStreetMap contributors

As an Amazon Associate, GrowersGuide.ca earns from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate disclosure.